India, Russia Share Online Olympiad Gold As Global Internet Outage Impacts Final
India and Russia both received FIDE Online Olympiad gold medals after a ruling from FIDE President Arkady Dvorkovich as Sunday's final was marred by a major internet disruption.
Five weeks of online play with more than 1,500 international participants deserved a final match that would be decided on the chessboard—and of course, a winner. Instead, the tournament ended in an anticlimax on Sunday.
Unlike other sports, chess has been blessed with the possibility of holding numerous tournaments online during the past few months. During this Online Olympiad, which saw connection problems in the division stage as well as the semifinals and final, one of the downsides of online play was revealed once again.
India-Russia
Bo. | 1 | India | Rtg | 3 : 3 | 2 | Russia | Rtg |
1.1 | GM | Vidit, Santosh Gujrathi | 2636 | ½ - ½ | GM | Nepomniachtchi, Ian | 2778 |
1.2 | GM | Harikrishna, Pentala | 2690 | ½ - ½ | GM | Artemiev, Vladislav | 2769 |
1.3 | GM | Koneru, Humpy | 2483 | ½ - ½ | GM | Lagno, Kateryna | 2521 |
1.4 | GM | Harika, Dronavalli | 2450 | ½ - ½ | GM | Kosteniuk, Alexandra | 2517 |
1.5 | GM | Praggnanandhaa, R | 1781 | ½ - ½ | GM | Sarana, Alexey | 2618 |
1.6 | WIM | Divya, Deshmukh | 1775 | ½ - ½ | WGM | Shuvalova, Polina | 2379 |
Bo. | 2 | Russia | Rtg | 2½:1½ | 1 | India | Rtg |
1.1 | GM | Nepomniachtchi, Ian | 2778 | ½ - ½ | GM | Anand, Viswanathan | 2751 |
1.2 | GM | Dubov, Daniil | 2770 | ½ - ½ | GM | Vidit, Santosh Gujrathi | 2636 |
1.3 | GM | Goryachkina, Aleksandra | 2502 | 1 - 0 | GM | Koneru, Humpy | 2483 |
1.4 | GM | Kosteniuk, Alexandra | 2517 | ½ - ½ | GM | Harika, Dronavalli | 2450 |
1.5 | GM | Esipenko, Andrey | 2629 | GM | Nihal, Sarin | 2418 | |
1.6 | WGM | Shuvalova, Polina | 2379 | WIM | Divya, Deshmukh | 1775 |
The day started with a hard-fought first match that finished in a 3-3 tie after all six games ended in a draw. A highly interesting encounter was the clash between GMs Humpy Koneru and Kateryna Lagno, where the Indian player missed a win at the very end:
The second match saw three draws and a win for GM Aleksandra Goryachkina vs. Koneru on the top four boards. On the lowest boards, the two players from India, GM Nihal Sarin and WIM Divya Deshmukh, both lost on time due to a disconnection.
Like Armenia in the semifinal, India appealed the final score. Unlike in the semifinal, this time a very clear, external reason for the connection problem was revealed: a major global internet outage of such proportions that it made the news reports of CNN, MSN, Newsweek, Forbes, and many other media outlets.
Provided with server data and other information by Chess.com, the appeals committee couldn't arrive at a unanimous decision to resolve the situation; therefore, the FIDE president declared both countries as joint winners.
Commenting to ESPN India, GM Viswanathan Anand said he didn't expect this decision. "At the end of the day, I think it's quite fair because both teams were evenly balanced in this match. It's certainly a nice and pleasant turn."
The Online Olympiad was followed closely by chess fans in India, which has celebrated a chess boom during the past few weeks. This was illustrated by the fact that the hashtag #ChessOlympiad was the second-most trending topic in the country on Twitter on Sunday, helped by one particular tweet from none other than the prime minister himself.
Congratulations to our chess players for winning the FIDE Online #ChessOlympiad. Their hard work and dedication are admirable. Their success will surely motivate other chess players. I would like to congratulate the Russian team as well.
— Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) August 30, 2020
Meanwhile, members of team Russia were less pleased with the outcome...
Let’s clarify one thing: India didn’t win the Olympiad, but was rather named by FIDE a co-champion. imho, there is a huge difference between actually “winning” the gold or just being awarded one without winning a single game in the final #onlineolympiad
— Alexandra Kosteniuk (@chessqueen) August 30, 2020
Smart desicion to please Indian chess community, meanwhile forgetting about other fans & players. Selective nobleness. @FIDE_chess #ChessOlympiad #Chess
— Yan Nepomniachtchi (@lachesisq) August 30, 2020
...while some neutral viewers could find some humor in it all.
Actually, each of the 8 Candidates getting a World Championship match against Magnus Carlsen is fine with me as well.♟️#Candidates2020
— Anish Giri (@anishgiri) August 30, 2020
Final | All games
The FIDE Online Olympiad was a major online chess event for national teams that ran July 25-August 30 on the Chess.com server. More than 1,500 participants and 163 teams from all over the world played.
Each team consisted of six players, including at least two women, at least one player who is 20 or younger, and at least one female player who is 20 or younger. The time control for all matches was 15 minutes for the game and a five-second increment per move, starting from move one.
Related articles:
- FIDE Online Chess Olympiad (info article)
- FIDE Online Olympiad Launches July 25 On Chess.com
- FIDE Online Olympiad: Base Division's Results
- Hong Kong, Angola Perfect, Eid Brilliant In Olympiad Division 4
- GM Zaibi Plays Brilliant Checkmate In Olympiad Division 3
- Shirov On Fire As Online Olympiad Gets Set For Top Division
- Azerbaijan, India, Russia, U.S. Pool Leaders At Online Olympiad
- Crunch Time For Online Olympiad's Top Division
- FIDE Online Olympiad: Who Made It To The Playoffs?
- Armenia, Hungary, Poland, Ukraine Enter Friday's Online Olympiad Quarterfinals
- India, Poland, Russia, U.S. In Saturday's Online Olympiad Semifinals
- India, Russia To Play Sunday's Online Olympiad Final