Forums

PUZZLE

Sort:
GINOPFRITZ


Alex_M
This is not a puzzle, merely a position. You need to specify the correct moves.
Alex_M
I see a mate in 3: 1. Qf5+ Bd3 2. Qxd3+ Kb3 3. Nd5#
Alex_M
I now see your mate in 2: 1. Qf5+ Kb3 2. Qb1#. However, Kb1 is not forced so it is not a force mate in 2 and is therefore considered a flawed puzzle.
neneko

Either I'm missing something or there isn't any forced mate in 2

Here's my 3 move mate

1 Ra2+ Bxa2

2 Qxa2+ Kc1

3 Ne2# 


x-5058622868

There is a mate in 2. Puzzle with solution here:


Alex_M
Sunshiny wrote: There is a mate in 2.

Where? In saying that I'd expect you to know where it is.

Beautiful mate neneko. Didn't see that one.


neneko
Sunshiny, and if black play 1..Bxb5?
x-5058622868
Both puzzle answers i posted has the same 1st move, but a different second move. I didn't bother erasing one if someone wanted to see both solutions. There's also a third different second move, but i'm sure people will see that after noticing the 1st move.
x-5058622868
neneko wrote: Sunshiny, and if black play 1..Bxb5?

 Ooh, good one. Didn't see that. Maybe there isn't a mate in 2? Let me look further...

Yeah, i don't see anything to continue a mate in 2 after that move. No mate in 2 after all. 

I think his new puzzle with the correction solves that problem.

I just looked at it, and it doesn't solve the problem. The flaw would be fixed here if the queen was on d5. 


x-5058622868
Nevermind. It still doesn't fix the flaw.
x-5058622868
benws wrote: Sunshiny wrote: Nevermind. It still doesn't fix the flaw.

What flaw? how does Black avoid mate after 1. Na2?


 1. ... Bxe6


x-5058622868
Or do you mean the other puzzle? I just went back to look at the other puzzle, and you're right that the puzzle over there isn't flawed.