Forums

Which is better? Caro-Kann or Sicillian?

Sort:
BlunderKing1987

Certainly Sicilian, only not if played by me. I will remember this loss forever and will have to live with it. A total newbie just got me, throwing stupid sidepawns from both sides like a madman. unfortunately, it was enough to secure his victory. I will have to stick to the most boring Italian - the guico pianissimo version, which my white opponents love so much. But Sicilian, to me it is too dangerous and some newbie strategies unfortunately proved to be succesful against me. I guess in the boring -a s s Italian, people just chill the whole game and nothing happens. But I got punished for trying to avoid this boring version.

MaetsNori
Doctor-Advanced-Pawns wrote:

Lately after studying a lot l came up with the 2 best options- Caro-Kann and Sicillian defence. So l just wanted to know which one is better so l can score some wins.

There's no wrong answer here - they're both sound defenses. Give them both a try, alternating between them from game to game. Eventually you'll decide that you like one more than the other. Then you can focus on that one.

ChessMasteryOfficial

The choice between the Caro-Kann Defense and the Sicilian Defense depends on your playing style, goals, and willingness to study theory.

Compadre_J

I never recommend the Sicilian to Beginners because it has a Lag in development + most Sicilian lines beginners like to play can get them into trouble.

I don’t like recommending the Kings Pawn game 1…e5 to beginners because I think players playing white will expect it and feel pretty comfortable seeing it.

The only 1…e5 line I have ever recommended to beginners is Philidor, but I often tell them to use the Pirc Move Order.

—————————————

The Main Black Opening lines I recommend to beginners would probably be:

- French Defense

- Caro Kann

I often recommend the above lines if a chess player is serious about improving.

If a player isn’t serious and just wants to have fun, I do like recommending other WEIRD Stuff.

- Modern Defense which can include:

1) Lizard Defense

2) Hippo Defense

3) Pterodactyl Defense

- Pirc Defense

Ziryab

Beginners need tactics. Nothing develops these faster than meeting 1.e4 with 1…e5, but the Sicilian does almost as well.