Forums

can a 900 beat a 1800?

Sort:
pranavravella

probably

pranavravella
  • I mean a horible 900
pranavravella

I know

3FFA

Yes, yes I can. :P

USCF 898. ^^

TheGreatOogieBoogie

Yeah... if they spent at least a year with good coaching and studying while not playing rated games during that time.  Otherwise no, 900s are too careless. 

pranavravella

your horrible??

3FFA
pranavravella wrote:

your horrible??

I'm not? Surprised

pranavravella

THINK YOU AREN'T  i' horible I used to have a rating of 724

CP6033

1 in 1000 games maybe, blitz maybe, slow games where they were concentrating? not a chance!

pranavravella

probably bullet. \

3FFA
pranavravella wrote:

probably bullet. \

If bullet I would actually be more likely to lose. :P

Aksyonov
pranavravella wrote:
I mean a horible 900

There are no horrible or superior 900's.  There are just 900's.

The Elo is just a mathematical representation of how often a player of a given rating will beat a player of a different rating.  Thus, all 900's, no matter how talented you perceive them to be, will beat 1800's at the same rate out of all games played.

That rate will not be very high, but will be no different from how often a 2000 rated player will beat Magnus Carlsen, in theory.

pranavravella
Aksyonov wrote:
pranavravella wrote:
I mean a horible 900

There are no horrible or superior 900's.  There are just 900's.

The Elo is just a mathematical representation of how often a player of a given rating will beat a player of a different rating.  Thus, all 900's, no matter how talented you perceive them to be, will beat 1800's at the same rate out of all games played.

That rate will not be very high, but will be no different from how often a 2000 rated player will beat Magnus Carlsen, in theory.

really

pranavravella

drawing 

pranavravella

nt

JamesColeman

That rate will not be very high, but will be no different from how often a 2000 rated player will beat Magnus Carlsen, in theory.

While that may or may not be true in theory, I suspect not true in reality.

pranavravella

why?????:0

eatdust

never we have a better chance agaist the champ!!!!!!

JamesColeman

Because you might get an 1800 who is old, out of practice, over rated, you might also get a 900 rated junior who is rapidly improving whose rating hasn't caught up with him, and vastly underrated. I've coached juniors with ridiculously low ratings relative to their ability. In that scenario you can easily envisage a surprise.

Carlsen is Carlsen. By the same token you're less likely to get a 2000 who should be several hundred points higher. I would say a 2000's chances vs Magnus are borderline non-existant. And even including the word borderline is being generous.

cvetlicnivitez

no, its impossible. i am a solid 1200-1300 player, and out of 100 tries 900 guy will beat me maximum 5 times...